Service Planning

An AI Tutor That Knows Your Learning Context, Not One Feedback for Everyone

Project Overview

Ringle's AI speaking feedback comes in the same structure for every learner. As team lead, I took the project from research to screen design, planning an experience where learners choose the depth, focus, timing, and tone of feedback and the AI coaches to their context.

View as PDF (Korean)
Project type
Team Project (Team Lead, 4 people)
Duration
3 Months
Role
Team Lead, Research Design, Problem Definition, Screen Design
Tools
Figma, FigJam, Google Forms

Background

AI speaking has improved. Why isn't it used as a learning tool?

Is the problem the technology, or the design of the learning experience?

Ringle teaches English through real conversations with native tutors. AI speaking is a chance to bring that experience to more people, but learners were not turning conversations with AI into steady study. This project set out to find out why, and to design personalized feedback that fits each learner’s context. We followed the Double Diamond process throughout. The screens and research materials are in Korean, as the project was done for a Korean service.

Double Diamond process
Double Diamond process

Key Features

AI tutor recommendation
AI tutor recommendation

A tutor the AI recommends and you keep

The AI first suggests a tutor and a feedback style that fit the chosen scenario. Learners can save it as is, ask for another recommendation, or edit it themselves.

Detailed feedback settings
Detailed feedback settings

Set the depth, focus, timing, and tone of feedback

From a one-line summary to a detailed explanation, from pronunciation to logical structure. Learners adjust how they receive feedback along four axes to match their level and purpose.

Answer analysis and correction
Answer analysis and correction

Fix it right after speaking, then say it again

With timing set to real time, the corrected sentence and the reason appear right after each answer. Learners repeat the corrected sentence and finish the practice on the spot.

Review complete with AI summary
Review complete with AI summary

One line at the end on what got better

When a session or review ends, the AI tutor sums up the key point in one line. Learners see where they improved without reading a long report.

Discover

Why don’t learners use AI speaking well as a learning tool?

Academic Research

Six factors that shape the learning experience

We analyzed 17 academic studies on AI-based language learning and grouped the key factors into six. What the studies pointed to was not speech recognition or model accuracy. The problem with AI speaking is not technical performance but the design of the learning experience.

Six factors that affect the AI speaking experience
Six factors that affect the AI speaking experience

SWOT Analysis

Ringle's core strength and its limit

Ringle’s strength is the natural expressions and real-world practice that come from talking with native tutors. But a tutor-centered service is costly to run and scale, from tutor quality control to lesson cost. We saw the AI tutor not as a replacement but as a way to complement and extend that experience.

SWOT analysis
SWOT analysis

Competitor Research

What learning experience do AI speaking services offer?

We compared five services in Korea and abroad, Speak, Loora, ELSA Speak, ChatGPT, and Speaking Max AI, by target, core value, strengths, and weaknesses. Most offered varied study modes and AI conversation practice, but they were built around single features, so the experience felt fragmented and little was designed to carry the learner’s flow forward.

Comparison of five AI English learning services
Comparison of five AI English learning services

Survey

What do learners want most from AI speaking?

There were already plenty of features. To see which ones learners actually care about, we surveyed 46 people. The most expected feature was a personalized study plan (65.4%), and the strongest motivator was personalized learning (77.8%). Learning flow was named both as the top thing to improve and as the hardest moment while studying (44.4% each).

Survey summary (46 respondents)
Survey summary (46 respondents)

1:1 In-depth Interviews

The core issue: feedback that isn't personalized

To understand the pattern of personalization and learning flow from the survey, we ran 1:1 in-depth interviews and grouped what people said with affinity mapping. Where two clusters overlapped, AI feedback experience and personalized learning experience, personalized feedback based on learning context emerged as the core problem.

Affinity mapping and resulting categories
Affinity mapping and resulting categories

Define: Problem Statement

Learners expect tailored feedback, but today’s feedback is the same for everyone.

Persona

Jieun Kim, a third-year marketer uneasy with business English

We turned the research into a persona that captures the goals, difficulties, and learning context of an AI speaking learner. Jieun Kim is a 28-year-old marketer who can handle everyday conversation but finds business English a burden. Being told a sentence is wrong is not enough for her. She wants to know what to fix first, given her situation and level.

Persona: goals, pain points, needs
Persona: goals, pain points, needs

Develop

How might we design AI-based personalized feedback that reflects the learner’s context?

Brainstorming

From problem statement to an HMW question

We turned the problem statement into a single How Might We question, and the whole team generated ideas that answer it.

Brainstorming
Brainstorming

Value Map

From same-structure feedback to AI coaching

We matched learners’ jobs, pains, and gains against the value Ringle can offer and narrowed the direction to one sentence. Ringle moves away from same-structure feedback and offers AI coaching feedback whose depth and link to action adjust to the learner’s context.

Value map
Value map

2×2 Prioritization Matrix

High impact, low effort first

We placed the ideas on two axes, impact and effort, to set the MVP scope. We chose to start with correcting and reviewing right after a conversation, feedback types that change with user data, a feedback filter, and key feedback. Level-based hints and tap-to-expand detailed feedback were left for the next phase.

Priorities by impact and effort
Priorities by impact and effort

User Flow

Tutor setup, conversation, summary, and review as one flow

Learning flow was the most common complaint in the survey, so we placed feedback settings between choosing a scenario and starting the conversation instead of in a separate menu. After a session, the summary feedback leads straight into review.

User flow
User flow

Deliver

How does tailored feedback look on screen, and how does it carry on?

Screens 1–4

Setting up the AI tutor and feedback style

Learners use the feedback style the AI recommends or change it themselves to build a feedback setup that fits their current situation.

01. Create AI tutor

A tutor that fits the scenario is created with default feedback settings.
A tutor that fits the scenario is created with default feedback settings.

02. AI recommendation

Tapping recommend suggests another tutor and style for the learner’s context.
Tapping recommend suggests another tutor and style for the learner’s context.

03. Detailed settings

Learners pick the depth and amount, focus areas, timing, and tone.
Learners pick the depth and amount, focus areas, timing, and tone.

04. Before the conversation

Learners check the scenario and saved tutor, then start.
Learners check the scenario and saved tutor, then start.

Screens 5–8

Correct while talking, get a summary at the end

The role-play conversation runs in the chosen feedback style. Learners practice on the spot with real-time correction and repeat-after speaking, then check the result in the AI summary.

05. Role-play conversation

The AI tutor asks a question for the situation and the learner answers by voice.
The AI tutor asks a question for the situation and the learner answers by voice.

06. Analysis and correction

The corrected sentence, the error, and the reason appear right under the answer.
The corrected sentence, the error, and the reason appear right under the answer.

07. Corrected sentence spoken

Saying the corrected sentence accurately earns positive feedback and moves on.
Saying the corrected sentence accurately earns positive feedback and moves on.

08. Session complete

One line of key feedback, study time, and expressions learned, leading into review.
One line of key feedback, study time, and expressions learned, leading into review.

Screens 9–11

Reviewing and moving to the next level

Learners review by talking through a scenario they studied before. Once they use all the target expressions, the AI judges their level and suggests the next step, then sums up the review in one line.

09. Review in progress

Target expressions for this review and whether they were used sit above the chat.
Target expressions for this review and whether they were used sit above the chat.

10. Goal reached

When every goal is met, the tutor asks whether to raise the level or stay.
When every goal is met, the tutor asks whether to raise the level or stay.

11. Review complete

What improved in the review is summed up in one line.
What improved in the review is summed up in one line.

Final Screens

An AI tutor that knows your learning context

Takeaways

What I learned from this project

01Finding the problem in the learning flow, not in features

At first I looked for which feature was missing. But the academic studies, the survey, and the interviews all pointed to the same place. Learners were stopping not because a feature was absent but because feedback did not connect to their own context. I learned to narrow a problem by layering different kinds of research.

02Getting the team to look at the same sentence

As team lead, what I worked on hardest was the one-sentence problem statement. Whenever the four of us pictured different solutions, we went back to that sentence to decide, which kept us steady through both widening and narrowing ideas.

03AI personalization has to be adjustable by the user

It is hard to earn trust when the AI simply adapts on its own. I came to think personalization starts with the AI recommending while the learner can always see why and change it. As a next step, I want to test this assumption with a prototype and usability testing.

Other projects

← All case studies